Psychological thrillers are undoubtedly the most popular subgenre of thriller movies, and there's a good reason for that. Thrillers generally mesh well with almost every genre. Combine them with the supernatural and you get a masterpiece like Sinners. Mix them with sci-fi and you get Minority Report. But psychological thrillers hit much closer to home because they feel real.
There are no vampires, no futuristic algorithms, just people. Messed-up, complex people. They take away the safety of make-believe worlds and drag you into the raw, uncomfortable corners of the human mind. So, if you're looking for dark psychological thrillers that will hook you from the very first scene, these 10 picks are a must-watch.
10 'Split' (2016)
M. Night Shyamalan's Split follows a man who suffers from dissociative identity disorder and lives with 23 different personalities inside him. Each one is completely unique, and James McAvoy is phenomenal in the role. He switches between these identities so effortlessly that it feels like you are watching multiple actors in one body.
The story kicks off when one of his personalities kidnaps three teenage girls and locks them in a basement. From that point on, every scene feels like a ticking time bomb as the girls try to look for ways to escape. They even attempt to use his fractured identities against him. But you're constantly on edge because you never know when the switch will happen, or which personality will come next.
9 'The Game' (1997)
David Fincher's The Game follows Nicholas Van Orton (Michael Douglas), a wealthy and self-absorbed businessman who gets a strange birthday gift from his brother. It's an invite to a company that promises a highly secretive game designed just for him. Nicholas has no idea when it will start or what the objective is, but when it finally begins, it seeps into every part of his life and blurs the line between reality and illusion.
The film feels like a darker, more twisted version of The Truman Show, but here you only know what Nicholas knows. You're just as unsure about what's real and what's part of the setup. There are shocking twists at every turn, and just when you think you've figured it out, the movie hits you with another curveball. That's why, even nearly three decades later, The Game stands as one of the greatest psychological thrillers ever made.
8 'It's What's Inside' (2024)
It's What's Inside feels like the game Among Us brought to life. The story takes place during a reunion of old college friends. Everything seems normal until a surprise guest shows up with a briefcase that can switch people's minds with one another. It begins as a fun party game; they jump into each other's bodies and mingle around, and try to guess who is who. If you've seen Bodies Bodies Bodies or Talk to Me, it's very much in that same vein.
But the movie quickly descends into pure paranoia. Every single relationship feels fragile because these friends share a long history full of baggage, secrets, and things left unsaid. And now, with everyone swapping identities, all that hidden drama comes crashing to the surface. The film also looks amazing. The camera work pops with bright colors that sell the party vibe. The editing is extremely fast-paced and chaotic, almost comic book-like. And the way this film handles flashbacks is one of the most creative things you will ever see in a movie.
7 'Juror #2' (2024)
Juror #2 is a slow-burn courtroom drama. The film stars Nicholas Hoult as an ordinary family man who gets selected for jury duty on a murder trial. However, as he learns more about the case, he realizes that the victim sounds a lot like someone he might have hit in an accident a while back. Back then, he thought it was just a deer and drove off. Now he starts to wonder if he actually killed a person. The film follows him as he wrestles between confessing or staying silent and watching someone else take the fall for his crime.
It's a simple story; the kind Hollywood rarely makes anymore. But it hits hard because it feels real. This is the kind of situation that could happen to anyone, and it probably has countless times. And Clint Eastwood's elegant direction takes that simplicity and turns it into something powerful. The film holds an impressive 93% critic score and a 90% audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
6 'Nocturnal Animals' (2016)
Nocturnal Animals is one of the best revenge films ever made. It follows an art gallery owner, Susan (Amy Adams), who hasn't spoken to her ex-husband Edward (Jake Gyllenhaal) in 20 years. But one day, she receives a surprise manuscript he wrote and dedicated to her.
As she starts reading it, the film moves back and forth between two plotlines. The first is the story inside the book, where a man seeks revenge on those who raped and killed his family. The second shows Susan's reactions as the book forces her to reflect on her past marriage and how it fell apart. And both stories slowly build toward a gut-punch ending that'll leave you feeling empty for days.
5 'Heretic' (2024)
Heretic centers on two Mormon missionaries out spreading their faith when they come across Mr. Reed's (Hugh Grant) house, and he invites them inside. Things quickly go downhill when Mr. Reed reveals he's an atheist and that the front door is locked and won't open until morning. If they want to leave, the girls must take part in a series of psychological games that push their faith and morality to the breaking point.
The film is written by Scott Beck and Bryan Woods, the duo behind A Quiet Place, and the writing is just as phenomenal here. It's packed with thought-provoking dialogue about the origins and validity of religion, its followers, and the institutions that uphold it. You'll even find yourself agreeing with some of the arguments made by Mr. Reed, even if you don't want to. At the same time, the movie gives equal weight to the missionaries' perspectives, which makes it a fascinating back-and-forth. If you're interested in religious philosophy, Heretic is definitely worth watching.
4 'Shutter Island' (2010)
If Martin Scorsese and Leonardo DiCaprio team up for a movie, you can bet it's going to land on the greatest-of-all-time lists, no matter the genre. That's exactly what happens with Shutter Island. The film follows two U.S. Marshals who travel to a mental institution on a remote island to investigate a patient's mysterious disappearance. But as the investigation progresses, the lead character Teddy (DiCaprio) starts losing his grip on reality.
When Teddy walks through the asylum's dark hallways, one of the patients whispers to him, "Don't you get it? You're a rat in a maze." And so is the audience. Scorsese has masterfully designed this movie to mess with your head at every turn. There are deliberate continuity errors that make you feel like something is off. Every conversation, every hallway, and every clue seems like it's leading to an answer, but it only pulls you deeper into confusion. You won't truly know what's going on until the last few minutes, and when the twist hits, it's so shocking you'll want to rewatch the entire movie immediately.
3 'Joker' (2019)
Joker asks the question: What do you get when you cross a mentally ill loner with a society that abandons him and treats him like trash? And it answers that with one of the most intense and unforgettable character studies ever put on screen. The story follows Arthur Fleck (Joaquin Phoenix), a struggling comedian who can't catch a break. He's lonely, broke, and lives with a condition that makes him laugh uncontrollably at the worst possible times. Society keeps kicking him down, and every hit pushes him closer to the edge until he finally snaps and becomes the Joker.
Phoenix completely disappears in the role as he mentally, emotionally, and physically transforms himself to embody Arthur's descent into madness. He delivers a performance that makes you fear him, pity him, and loathe him in equal measure, and it even earned him an Oscar for Best Actor. Todd Phillips nails the tone as well. There's a dark and brooding atmosphere that permeates the film and truly sells Gotham City as a powder keg that's ready to explode. The film also features an Oscar-winning original score that is just as haunting as what you're seeing on screen. All in all, Joker is a film that's a perfect 10/10 in every department and deserves to be seen at least once.
2 'Blink Twice' (2024)
It's best to go into Blink Twice without knowing too much, but here's the basic premise. The story follows a cocktail waitress who gets invited to a tech billionaire's private island for what seems like a dream vacation. At first, it's all good vibes, but as the days go on, she starts noticing strange things happening on the island. If you loved Midsommar, The Menu, or Get Out, this movie has the same unsettling energy but mixed with a lot more humor and wild party scenes.
This is Zoë Kravitz's directorial debut, and she absolutely nails it. The film is packed with mystery and tension that keeps you guessing all the way through. And when the truth finally comes out, it's one of the darkest things you'll see in a film. It perfectly exposes just how depraved and immoral the ultra-rich can be when they know no one can touch them.
1 'Nightcrawler' (2014)
Nightcrawler stars Jake Gyllenhaal in one of the greatest performances of his career as Lou Bloom, an unemployed man desperate for success. He stumbles into the world of crime journalism, buys a cheap camcorder and a police scanner, and starts filming grisly accidents and crime scenes to sell the footage to news stations. But Lou's ambition for greatness keeps growing, and it pushes him into darker, more dangerous territory where human life is just another shot to sell, and he's willing to cross every moral line to get the perfect story.
This movie gives us one of the best portrayals of a sociopath ever put on screen. From the very first scene, you know something is seriously off about Lou. He's cold, manipulative, and talks almost entirely in recycled self-help lines from career seminars. He has zero empathy. He doesn't see blood and broken bones; he sees ratings and paychecks. And yet, even at his most depraved, you can't pull your eyes away from the screen because the performance is that good.
Your Rating close 10 stars 9 stars 8 stars 7 stars 6 stars 5 stars 4 stars 3 stars 2 stars 1 star Rate Now 0/10 Like Nightcrawler R Crime Drama Thriller 9.5/10 Release Date October 31, 2014 Runtime 117 Minutes Where to watch Close WHERE TO WATCH RENT BUY
Powered by Expand Collapse
Keep Reading: The 10 Greatest Psychological Thriller Movies of the Last 40 Years, Ranked